Well, I have to say that I’m rather disappointed with the 2008 Treasure Hunt at this point.
For one thing, the medallion is being found way too early each day. 6:45 AM is too early to give out the first clue anyway, and every medallion has been found by 9 AM this week. When I was able to go out and look for the medallion on a regular basis a few years ago, we enjoyed trying to figure out the clues and going different places throughout the day looking for the medallion. It was a very social event that a lot of people looked forward to. While the medallion was usually found early a day or two each year, there were always some days where the hunt went on for several hours. I think the sponsors that have been in charge of the Treasure Hunt since long-time sponsor AFG stopped running it a few years ago have forgotten many of the things that made it special. I’m not sure if the clues are too easy or if the medallion isn’t being hidden well enough, but the medallion shouldn’t be found so early every day.
Another thing about the Treasure Hunts from a few years ago is that the organizers would hide the medallion REALLY well. It wasn’t uncommon for masses of people to know what location the medallion was hidden at, but still be unable to find it for a few hours. That’s where the social aspect of the Treasure Hunt came in. People enjoyed socializing while looking for the medallion. For example, around 10-12 years ago, there was a Treasure Hunt that basically turned into an impromptu community picnic at Borden Park. Everyone was convinced the medallion was there, but it was hidden so well that it wasn’t found until the afternoon. In the meantime, everyone enjoyed hanging out in the park together. It was a fun day.
Something that bothered me about today’s hunt in particular is that I see absolutely no possible way that anyone could have found the medallion based on the first clue. My personal belief is that someone who wasn’t even participating in the Treasure Hunt stumbled across it. According to the Treasure Hunt web site, the medallion was found in the “wheels” paper box at the Kingsport Chamber of Commerce. The Kingsport Times-News publishes a publication called “Wheels” that contains listings of automobiles for sale, and I assume that is what they were referring to. Here’s the problem with hiding the medallion in such a location – if anyone comes along and opens the box to get a paper, aren’t they going to see the medallion in there? I’m guessing that is probably what happened.
Below is my analysis of today’s clues. Remember that the medallion was found after only the first clue had been given out.
Clue #1: Hang a left or a right at this traffic light.
OK, so this clue refers to a traffic light. However, you can turn left or right at almost every traffic light, so the clue doesn’t really narrow down which traffic light the medallion was hidden near. One of my friends pointed out that when you are coming down Broad Street towards the train station, you can only turn left or right at the traffic light at the intersection of Main and Broad. However, that isn’t technically true. While it isn’t a through street, you can still go straight through the light into a parking lot.
The traffic light in question is in front of the train station (which I think houses a bank), while the Chamber of Commerce is in the building to the left of the train station. Even if someone figured out which traffic light the clue was referring to (which I think is a stretch), there is nothing in the clue that would lead anyone to think they should go to a building down the street from the light and look in a paper box for the medallion. That’s why I think the person who found it was fortunate enough to stumble across a medallion worth $100 when they opened the box to get their paper. I would be very surprised if the person who found it was even looking for it. If anyone has any first-hand information to the contrary, please let me know.
Clue #2: Need new wheels? We’ve got deals
This is actually a good second clue. It applies to where the medallion was found, but it also would have thrown people off the trail. If I had heard this clue, I would have started looking near car lots. It’s good to have clues that provide a little bit of misdirection. That’s part of what makes the Treasure Hunt fun. Unfortunately, the medallion was found before this clue was given out.
Clue #3: Find me in a box near a clock
The clock tower in the train station is probably the most well-known clock in Kingsport, so I can see how this clue would lead people there. Once they figured out which clock was being referred to, they’d also realize which traffic light was being referred to in the first clue. I thought it was a little odd that the clue pointed to a building beside the one where the medallion was actually hidden, but I guess it was close enough to be considered “near”.
In closing, I think today’s set of clues was the best set of the week so far. It’s unfortunate that the hunt was derailed by what I believe to be a poor job of hiding the medallion. I believe it was in a place where it was likely that someone who wasn’t even looking for it would have run across it – and I assume that is what happened.
Update (7/18): Based on an article in today’s Kingsport Times-News, it appears that I was mistaken in my assumptions that nobody figured out yesterday’s clue and that someone who wasn’t looking for it just stumbled across the medallion. The article detailed how one group figured out where to go look, and also mentioned that there were a lot of people there looking for it. It also confirmed that the lady who found it was indeed looking for it.